Coaching / Tools & guides / Carbs are not the enemy: how many carbs you need, and when to eat them
Guide · Carbohydrates, fibre and meal timing

Carbs are not the enemy.

How many carbs you need, which ones your gut uses, and why it pays to eat them earlier in the day.

One worked example: a 35-year-old woman, 7,500 steps a day, strength training three times a week. Every number is shown step by step, in grams, with graphs you can switch between.

Continue where you left off
200–280 gcarbs a day at maintenance
30–35 gfibre a day, built up slowly
12 hovernight break, no late eating

The short answer

How many carbs a day does an active woman need?

Take a 35-year-old woman of 65 kg who walks 7,500 steps a day and lifts weights three times a week. At maintenance she needs roughly 200–280 g of carbohydrate a day: about 250 g on rest days and 325 g on training days at the top of her range. Carbs are an energy target, not a gut requirement. Her gut needs variety and 30–35 g of fibre, eaten mostly earlier in the day.

The seven rules this guide is built on

  1. 1Insulin naturally rises after meals. Keeping it flat is not the goal.A rise that comes back down within a couple of hours is how glucose gets into your muscles. See section 03.
  2. 2Your circadian rhythm helps regulate how your body handles food.The same meal gives a higher glucose response in the evening than in the morning [6].
  3. 3Fuel your morning with protein, healthy fats and fibre-rich carbohydrates.Breakfast is the largest meal in the sample day in section 04.
  4. 4Different fibres do different jobs along your gut, and some feed your gut bacteria.The gut map in section 02 shows where each type acts [4].
  5. 5Neither 20 g of carbs nor extreme fasting ensures autophagy or better health.What the studies can and cannot tell us is in section 03.
  6. 6Nourish well. Train earlier in the day. Sleep consistently.The sample training day puts the session at 10:00.
  7. 7If you choose to fast, favour an overnight break from food rather than late-night eating.A 12-hour overnight gap fits your body clock; a late snack works against it [10].
01 · How many carbs

How do you work out how many carbs you need?

You start from energy, not from carbs. First the calories you burn, then protein, then fat, and the carbs fill what is left. Here is the worked example, using the same equations as our maintenance calculator and macros calculator, so the numbers match.

The case study (assumptions)

An "average" woman, chosen to show the method. Your own numbers will differ, so use the sliders further down.

35years old
165 cmheight
65 kgweight, body fat not measured
7,500steps a day
3 × weekstrength training, mornings
Maintenancegoal: keep her weight
  1. Resting energy: what her body burns at rest

    Without a body fat measurement, our calculators use the revised Harris–Benedict equation for women [1].

    447.6 + 9.25 × 65 kg + 3.10 × 165 cm − 4.33 × 35 years

    ≈ 1,410 kcal a day

  2. Daily burn: add everyday life, steps and training

    Resting energy × 1.2 for everyday life, plus walking (about 0.0004 kcal per kg per step), plus 300 kcal per strength session spread over the week.

    1,690 + 195 for 7,500 steps + 130 for 3 sessions ÷ 7

    ≈ 2,010 kcal a day

  3. Maintenance range: aim for the top

    Maintenance is a band of about 500 kcal, not one number. WITH ME aims for the top of it: more food means more nutrients and more fuel for muscle. Training days get the session's 300 kcal on top.

    Range 1,760–2,260 kcal · rest day 2,130 · training day 2,430

    Average ≈ 2,260 kcal a day

  4. Protein first, the same every day

    Protein is set per kg of lean mass for her age band (31–40), at the top of the band because she trains three times a week. Estimated lean mass is about 46 kg. See our protein guide for the full table.

    46 kg lean mass × 2.3 g

    ≈ 105 g protein (420 kcal)

  5. Split what is left: 60 % carbs, 40 % fat

    Of the calories left after protein, 40 % go to fat and 60 % to carbs, our calculators' default. Fat stays the same every day; carbs move with training.

    Fat: (2,260 − 420) × 40 % ÷ 9 ≈ 80 g · Carbs: what remains ÷ 4

    Rest day ≈ 250 g carbs · training day ≈ 325 g · average ≈ 280 g

So, how many carbs?

At the top of her maintenance range: about 250 g on rest days and 325 g on training days. At the bottom of the range it would be about 200 g. That is why we give 200–280 g as her everyday window. Below about 200 g, her fibre target and her training both get harder to cover.

How the numbers shift for 60 kg and 70 kg

Weight60 kg65 kg70 kg
Maintenance, top2,1902,2602,330 kcal
Protein105 g105 g110 g
Carbs, rest day230 g250 g250 g
Carbs, training day305 g325 g325 g
Fibre22–33 g23–34 g23–35 g

Same height, age, steps and training. At 70 kg the extra calories go mostly to protein and fat, so carbs stay about the same. Fibre is our calculators' 10–15 g per 1,000 kcal.

Make it yours

Move the sliders to see your carbs and fibre

Age and height
250 gcarbs on a rest day
325 gcarbs on a training day
23–34 gfibre a day
2,260kcal, top of maintenance

Protein 105 g and fat 80 g stay the same every day. At the bottom of your maintenance range, carbs would be about 200 g. For your gut, build fibre towards 30–35 g a day.

An estimate for women, without a body fat measurement. For your exact numbers, with body fat and your own split, use the maintenance calculator or the macros calculator. Your choices stay on this device only.

Why the number moves, and why that is fine

The carb figure is an energy budget. It goes up with steps, sessions and body size, and down when you are less active. Your gut does not count grams of carbohydrate. What it notices is how much fibre you eat, how varied it is, and how steadily you build it up. That is section 02.

02 · Your gut

Does each part of your gut need its own carbs?

Short answer

No. There is no gram quota for the stomach, small intestine or colon. Different carbohydrates act in different places: most starch and sugar is absorbed in the small intestine, while fibre and resistant starch travel on to the colon [2][4].

Tap a type to see where it acts.

Simple map of the gut: stomach, small intestine and colon Stomach Small intestine Colon (large intestine)
TypeWhere it actsWhat it doesFoods
Digestible starches and sugarsSmall intestineDigested and absorbed; energy for activity and trainingOats, rice, potatoes, bread, fruit
Gel-forming soluble fibreStomach and small intestineForms a gel; slows digestion and absorptionOats, soaked chia, psyllium
Fermentable fibre and resistant starchColonFermented by bacteria into short-chain fatty acids such as butyrateLentils, beans, onions, oats, cooled cooked potatoes, slightly green bananas
Bulking and water-holding fibreColonAdds bulk and holds water; helps stool form and passWhole grains, vegetables, seeds, psyllium

These groups overlap. Oats appear three times; psyllium is both gel-forming and bulking. Soluble fibre is not always gel-forming, and not every fibre is fermented to the same degree [4]. That is why variety matters more than any single "gut food".

How much fibre, and how fast?

EFSA considers 25 g of fibre a day adequate for normal bowel function in adults [2]. A large set of reviews for the World Health Organization found the lowest disease risk at 25–29 g a day or more (see referenced study [3]). Our gut rebuild guide builds towards 30–35 g. Start where you are and add about 5 g a week, with an extra glass of water each time.

25 gWeek 1
30 gWeek 2
33 gWeek 3
35 gWeek 4

Signs to slow down

  • Bloating or cramps that last most of the day, not just after one meal.
  • Much more gas than usual for more than a few days.
  • Stools that become much harder or much looser.

If that happens, go back to the last amount that felt comfortable for a week, drink more water, then add fibre in smaller steps.

If your gut is sensitive. With IBS, IBD or after gut surgery, build fibre with your doctor or a dietitian. Gentler, less fermentable fibres such as psyllium are often easier than large amounts of beans, onions or inulin; in one study, psyllium reduced the gas produced by inulin in people with IBS (see referenced study [5]). Our gut rebuild guide covers this step by step.
03 · Why the morning

Why is it better to eat more of your carbs earlier in the day?

Short answer

Your body handles the same meal better in the morning. Studies found higher glucose after identical meals in the biological evening than in the morning, partly because the pancreas releases less insulin early on in the evening [6]. Eating close to bedtime, when melatonin is rising, lowers glucose tolerance further [10].

Insulin is supposed to rise

After a meal, glucose rises and insulin follows. Insulin moves that glucose into your muscles and liver, where it is used or stored as glycogen. A rise that settles within about two hours is normal and useful. Keeping insulin flat all day is not the goal. What matters is a response that stays high for hours, which is more likely when large meals come late at night.

The same meal, morning or evening

Switch between glucose and insulin, and turn each meal on or off.

Illustrative, based on published study data. Shapes drawn to match the reported differences: glucose after identical meals about 17 % higher in the biological evening, with about 27 % less early insulin [6]. Not a measurement of any one person.

What cortisol is doing in the morning

Cortisol is not only a stress hormone. It follows a daily rhythm: most of it is released in the hours around waking, with a sharp rise over the first 30–45 minutes after you wake up, called the cortisol awakening response. Researchers propose that this burst prepares the body for the demands of the day [7]. It then falls through the afternoon and is lowest around midnight.

Eating in the morning works with this rhythm. Meals act as a timing signal for the clocks in your organs: in one study, moving all meals 5 hours later moved the daily glucose rhythm by almost 6 hours (see referenced study [8]). In another, women who habitually skipped breakfast had higher cortisol from the morning to mid-afternoon than women who ate breakfast (see referenced study [9]).

What the evidence does not show. Breakfast does not "switch off" cortisol, and the breakfast-skipping study was small and observational: it shows a link, not cause and effect. What is clearer is that skipped meals, hard training and short sleep add up to a bigger load on your body. That is why we put fuel before and after morning sessions.

Your cortisol day, and where meals land

Compare an early eater with a late eater.

Illustrative, based on published study data. Daily cortisol shape and the awakening rise from [7]; the higher daytime line for the late eater reflects the breakfast-skipping study [9]; the grey band marks the evening rise in melatonin [10]. Waking at 06:30, sleeping at 23:00.

Late eating and melatonin

In the evening, melatonin rises to prepare you for sleep, and melatonin reduces how much insulin the pancreas releases. In a trial with 845 adults, the same glucose drink taken one hour before bedtime instead of four hours before gave 3.5 times more melatonin, 6.7 % less insulin and 8.3 % more glucose (see referenced study [10]). That is the reason for our one rule everywhere: the last meal about 4 hours before sleep.

An early dinner or a late snack: the night that follows

Glucose from 18:00 to 07:00.

Illustrative, based on published study data. The late snack meets rising melatonin, so less insulin is released and glucose stays up for longer [10]. Bedtime 23:00.

What you put on the breakfast plate matters too

A breakfast of white toast, jam and juice is absorbed fast. Protein, fat and fibre slow the meal down, so glucose rises less steeply and falls back more gently. In a small study in adults with type 2 diabetes, eating the protein and vegetables before the carbs of the same meal led to lower glucose and insulin afterwards (see referenced study [13]). In healthy people the effect is smaller, but the habit costs nothing.

Two breakfasts, the same morning

Glucose over 3 hours after breakfast.

Illustrative, based on published study data. Typical shapes for a fast-absorbed versus a mixed, fibre-rich breakfast; protein, fat and fibre slow gastric emptying and absorption [4][13].

What happens when the biggest meal moves to the morning

Two well-known trials point the same way. Women with metabolic syndrome eating the same 1,400 kcal lost more weight and waist, and had lower glucose and insulin, when 700 kcal came at breakfast rather than at dinner (see referenced study [11]). Men with prediabetes who ate all their food before 15:00, at the same calories, improved their insulin sensitivity without losing weight (see referenced study [12]). Both were small and in specific groups, and a 6-hour window is not what we suggest. The point is the direction: earlier is better than later.

Does 20 g of carbs or a long fast switch on autophagy?

Autophagy is the cells' own clean-up and recycling process, and fasting is one of its triggers. But most of what we know comes from animal and cell studies (see referenced study [14]), it is still hard to measure in living people, and no study has shown a carb number or a fasting length that reliably switches it on in humans. Very low-carb eating also makes 30 g of fibre and well-fuelled training much harder to reach. An overnight break of about 12 hours, without late eating, gives you a regular daily fast that fits your body clock.

Putting it into practice

  • Make breakfast your largest meal, built on protein, healthy fats and fibre-rich carbs.
  • On training days, put carbs before and after the session. Train earlier in the day where you can.
  • Let meals get smaller towards the evening, and finish eating about 4 hours before sleep.
  • If you want to fast, keep it to the night: 12–13 hours from dinner to breakfast.
  • Keep a regular sleep and wake time, so your meals and your body clock stay lined up.
04 · Put it together

What does a day of 250–325 g of carbs look like?

Here is the case study's day in grams, front-loaded, with fibre from vegetables, fruit, whole grains, legumes, nuts and seeds rather than from rice or bread alone. It is the built-up version, after the 4-week fibre ramp. Switch between a rest day and a training day.

249 g325 gcarbs
32.9 g36.6 gfibre
75 %82 %of carbs by 14:00
  1. 07:00Breakfast84 g carbs · 10.9 g fibre
    FoodAmountCarbsFibre
    Rolled oats (dry)50 g34 g5.0 g
    Greek yoghurt, plain 2 %200 g8 g0.0 g
    Blueberries100 g15 g2.4 g
    Walnuts15 g2 g1.0 g
    Eggs (2)100 g1 g0.0 g
    Wholegrain bread40 g16 g2.4 g
    Honey10 g8 g0.0 g

    Coffee goes here, with or after breakfast, not on an empty stomach.

  2. 10:30Mid-morning36 g carbs · 3.1 g fibre
    FoodAmountCarbsFibre
    Banana, just ripe120 g27 g3.1 g
    Plain kefir200 g9 g0.0 g
  3. 09:30Before training44 g carbs · 4.0 g fibre
    FoodAmountCarbsFibre
    Banana, just ripe120 g27 g3.1 g
    Rice cakes (2)20 g16 g0.8 g

    Easy-to-digest carbs, low in fibre and fat, so the session feels light.

  4. 11:30After training40 g carbs · 2.4 g fibre
    FoodAmountCarbsFibre
    Plain kefir250 g11 g0.0 g
    Honey15 g12 g0.0 g
    Wholegrain bread40 g16 g2.4 g

    Carbs to refill glycogen, with protein for recovery.

  5. 13:00Lunch68 g carbs · 9.9 g fibre
    FoodAmountCarbsFibre
    Potatoes, boiled and cooled250 g50 g4.5 g
    Lentils, cooked40 g8 g3.2 g
    Chicken breast, cooked120 g0 g0.0 g
    Tomatoes100 g4 g1.2 g
    Cucumber100 g4 g0.5 g
    Red onion30 g3 g0.5 g
    Extra virgin olive oil10 g0 g0.0 g

    Boil the potatoes the evening before and keep them in the fridge: cooling turns some of the starch into resistant starch.

  6. 13:30Lunch97 g carbs · 10.3 g fibre
    FoodAmountCarbsFibre
    Potatoes, boiled and cooled250 g50 g4.5 g
    Basmati rice, cooked100 g28 g0.4 g
    Lentils, cooked40 g8 g3.2 g
    Chicken breast, cooked120 g0 g0.0 g
    Tomatoes100 g4 g1.2 g
    Cucumber100 g4 g0.5 g
    Red onion30 g3 g0.5 g
    Extra virgin olive oil10 g0 g0.0 g

    The extra rice on training days covers the session. Eat the salad and chicken first, the starch last.

  7. 16:00Afternoon21 g carbs · 3.6 g fibre
    FoodAmountCarbsFibre
    Apple, with skin150 g21 g3.6 g
  8. 18:30Early dinner41 g carbs · 5.4 g fibre
    FoodAmountCarbsFibre
    Salmon, baked120 g0 g0.0 g
    Basmati rice, cooked100 g28 g0.4 g
    Broccoli, steamed80 g6 g2.6 g
    Carrots, cooked80 g7 g2.4 g
    Extra virgin olive oil5 g0 g0.0 g

    Finished by 19:00 for a 23:00 bedtime: about 12 hours before breakfast.

Values per 100 g from USDA FoodData Central [16], rounded; carbs include fibre, as our calculators count it. Protein comes from the eggs, yoghurt, kefir, chicken and salmon, and fat from the walnuts, olive oil, eggs and salmon. Weigh foods raw or cooked as written.

Where the carbs go, training day and rest day

Grams of carbs per meal. Turn each day on or off.

From the sample day above. Training day 325 g, rest day 249 g.

Training days and rest days

  • Training days: about 75 g more carbs, placed around the session: 30–45 g in the 60–90 minutes before, low in fibre and fat, and 40 g or more within about 2 hours after, with protein. Over a whole day, the total matters more than the exact minute [15].
  • Rest days: the same breakfast and protein, fewer starchy carbs at lunch, and more room for fibre-rich foods.
  • Both days: protein and fat stay the same; only carbs move.

Want this built around your own numbers and food preferences? The weekly meal planner does it for you, or talk to Alexandra about coaching.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

How many carbs a day does a woman who strength trains need?

It depends on her size and activity. For a 35-year-old woman of about 65 kg who walks 7,500 steps a day and lifts three times a week, maintenance works out at about 200–280 g of carbohydrate a day: about 250 g on rest days and 325 g on training days at the top of her range. Protein (about 105 g) and fat (about 80 g) stay the same every day.

Does my gut need a minimum amount of carbs?

There is no gram quota for each part of the gut. Most starch and sugar is absorbed in the small intestine, while fibre and resistant starch reach the colon, where bacteria ferment them. What your gut notices most is how much fibre you eat and how varied it is.

How much fibre should I eat a day?

EFSA considers 25 g a day adequate for normal bowel function in adults, and a large set of reviews found the lowest disease risk at 25–29 g a day or more. WITH ME guides build towards 30–35 g, adding about 5 g a week with extra water.

Is it better to eat carbs in the morning or at night?

Studies found that the same meal gives a higher glucose response in the evening than in the morning, and eating close to bedtime, when melatonin is rising, lowers glucose tolerance further. Front-loading carbs, with breakfast as the largest meal and the last meal about 4 hours before sleep, works with your body clock.

Does eating breakfast affect cortisol?

Cortisol naturally peaks in the first 30–45 minutes after waking. Breakfast works with this rhythm and helps set the clocks in your organs. One small study found higher daytime cortisol in women who habitually skipped breakfast, but it shows a link, not cause and effect.

Do 20 g of carbs or long fasts trigger autophagy?

Fasting is one trigger of autophagy, but most of the evidence comes from animal and cell studies, and no carb number or fasting length has been shown to reliably switch it on in humans. A regular overnight break of about 12 hours, without late eating, is a fast that fits your body clock.

What should I eat before and after strength training?

About 30–45 g of easy-to-digest carbs, low in fibre and fat, 60–90 minutes before, such as a banana and two rice cakes. Within about 2 hours after, 40 g or more of carbs with protein, such as kefir with honey and wholegrain bread. Over the day, the total matters more than the exact timing.

EN

Language

Changes the language only. Your delivery country, currency and cart stay as they are.

Waiting list

Join the WITH ME waiting list

Leave your email and we will write once, when WITH ME launches.

We use your email to tell you when this product launches. It is stored in our Shopify account; you can ask us to delete it at any time at contact@withmenutrition.com. See the Privacy policy.

Email Questions? Text Alexandra